Key points
- Moment frames allow open floor plans, but drift becomes harder to control as buildings get taller.
- Shear walls are very stiff and efficient against drift, but their positions fix the architectural layout.
- In a dual system, the moment frame must resist at least 25% of the design seismic force.
- Agree shear wall positions at concept stage to avoid torsion and repeated analysis.
Shear walls and moment frames are the two main ways a concrete building resists earthquakes. The choice between them, or a combination of both, shapes column sizes, wall positions, how free the architectural floor plan can be, and even how tall the building is allowed to go. This article explains how each system works in plain terms, so you can discuss it comfortably with your structural engineer.
Two ways a building resists earthquakes
During an earthquake the ground moves and the building is pushed sideways. These lateral forces must travel from every floor down to the foundation through a seismic force-resisting system. Indonesia's seismic code, SNI 1726:2019, lists these systems in a table with a response modification coefficient (R), an overstrength factor (Ω0), a deflection amplification factor (Cd) and height limits for each seismic design category.
For reinforced concrete buildings, three groups come up most often:
- Moment frames: beams and columns joined rigidly resist sideways forces by bending.
- Shear walls: very stiff concrete walls carry most of the lateral load.
- Dual systems: moment frames and shear walls working together.
A higher R value means the design seismic force may be reduced further, but in return the system must meet stricter detailing so it can deform without collapsing. The thinking behind this is explained in force-based vs performance-based design.
Moment frames: freedom in the floor plan
In a moment frame, beams and columns form portals. When the building sways, the rigid beam-column joints resist rotation, so the members bend and pass the force downwards. In high-seismic areas the system used is the special moment frame. In the SNI 1726:2019 table, special reinforced concrete moment frames have R = 8, Ω0 = 3 and Cd = 5.5, with no height limit in seismic design categories B to F.
Advantages of moment frames:
- Open floor plans, with no solid walls locking the layout.
- Well suited to lobbies, meeting halls and retail floors.
- Ductile behaviour when detailed correctly.
The drawback is flexibility. As buildings get taller, storey drift becomes hard to control without enlarging columns and beams. Frames must also follow the strong column, weak beam principle: plastic hinges are meant to form at beam ends rather than in columns, to avoid a single-storey (soft storey) collapse.
Shear walls: stiff and efficient against drift
A shear wall is a long, thick reinforced concrete wall, usually placed around the lift and stair core (a core wall) or along the sides of the building. Because its moment of inertia is far larger than a column's, it is very effective at limiting sideways drift.
Special reinforced concrete shear walls are designed to yield in flexure near their base, while brittle shear failure is prevented by providing extra shear capacity. Wall ends often need special boundary elements, closely spaced hoops that confine the concrete under high compression. Where two walls are linked by short beams above door openings, these coupling beams absorb earthquake energy before hinges form at the wall base.
In ASCE 7-16, the standard SNI 1726:2019 is based on, special reinforced concrete shear walls have R = 5 when they also carry the main gravity loads (bearing wall system) and R = 6 when gravity is carried by a frame (building frame system). Both are height-limited in seismic design categories D, E and F: 160 ft (about 49 m) in D and E and 100 ft (about 30 m) in F, unless special provisions are met. This is one reason tall buildings in seismic regions usually use a dual system.
Tip: Agree shear wall positions at the architectural concept stage. Walls placed asymmetrically can make the building twist (torsion) during an earthquake, and moving them late almost always means redoing the analysis.
Dual systems: the best of both
A dual system combines shear walls with moment frames. The walls provide stiffness to control drift; the frame provides ductility and acts as a second line of defence. SNI 1726:2019 requires the moment frame in a dual system to resist at least 25% of the design seismic force, so the building still has another lateral load path if the walls are damaged.
In ASCE 7-16, a dual system with special moment frames and special reinforced concrete shear walls has R = 7 and no height limit in any seismic design category. That is why it is common in tall apartments, hotels and offices, such as the apartment and high-rise projects Stadin has engineered.
Quick comparison
| Aspect | Moment frame | Shear wall |
|---|---|---|
| Lateral stiffness | Low to medium | High |
| Floor plan freedom | Very flexible | Limited by wall positions |
| Height limit (SDC D–F) | None (special frame) | Limited, except in dual systems |
| Critical details | Beam-column joints, strong column weak beam | Boundary elements, coupling beams |
These points are general. The final choice depends on building height, the site's seismic design category, soil conditions, building use and coordination with the architect and MEP engineers.
Impact on architecture and cost
For owners, the structural system shows up directly in the floor plan. Shear walls usually sit around lifts, stairs and shafts, which keeps the building perimeter more open. A pure frame gives the most flexible plan, but columns and beams tend to grow in tall buildings. A dual system is often an efficient compromise.
Things to settle early:
- Define the use of each floor, especially podium floors that need long spans.
- Fix the positions of lift and stair cores before the plan is frozen.
- Avoid sudden changes in stiffness between storeys, such as walls that stop at a certain level.
- Involve the structural engineer before schematic design is finished, not after.
The structural system also determines how the building performs in a major earthquake. How that performance is judged is explained in structural performance levels.
Conclusion
Moment frames excel in plan freedom and ductility, shear walls in stiffness, and dual systems combine both for tall buildings in seismic areas. No system is always best: the right one comes from seismic analysis, soil data and coordination with the architecture, and every member size must be calculated by a competent engineer. To discuss the structural system for your building, talk to Stadin about structural design.
This article provides general information. Every project still needs to be analysed and calculated by a competent structural or geotechnical engineer, in line with the applicable SNI codes and regulations.

